Navigating the Noise: Stoic Wisdom in a Digital Age
by Donavon L Riley


In the digital age, where opinions flood our feeds and perspectives clash on every issue, the words of Marcus Aurelius resonate even more profoundly: “Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth.” In this interconnected web of information and influence, let’s unravel the modern relevance of these Stoic principles as we navigate the sea of subjectivity, equipped with practical examples to understand and apply these timeless teachings.

Sorting Signals from Noise

In a world where the information landscape is as vast as it is varied, Aurelius’ call to recognize that what we hear is an opinion urges us to exercise digital humility. Take, for instance, a viral tweet proclaiming a groundbreaking scientific discovery. Before accepting it as gospel, the Stoic approach encourages us to pause and evaluate. Who is the source? Is it a reputable scientist or a self-proclaimed expert? What biases might be at play? This discernment, akin to a Stoic filter, enables us to sift through the noise and distill meaningful insights.

Moreover, consider the broader implications of digital humility when engaging with online content. Whether it’s news articles, blog posts, or social media updates, acknowledging the subjective nature of what we consume allows us to approach information with a critical yet open mind. In adopting this Stoic lens, we not only become mindful consumers of content but also active participants in shaping the narrative of our digital experience.

Social Media Drama

Social media, a battleground of opinions, often sparks emotional reactions. Imagine encountering a heated debate on a divisive topic. The Stoic response, inspired by Aurelius, involves a pause for reflection. Rather than being swayed by the emotional currents, a Stoic mind strives for equanimity. By questioning assumptions and considering alternative perspectives, we can engage in constructive dialogue rather than adding to the cacophony of online disputes.

For example, picture a thread discussing the societal impact of a certain lifestyle choice. Instead of immediately taking sides, a Stoic approach prompts us to examine the arguments objectively. Are there valid points on both sides? What assumptions are underlying the differing opinions? This Stoic equanimity allows us to contribute to the conversation thoughtfully, fostering a more constructive online environment.

Media Literacy

In an era where everyone can be a content creator, Aurelius’ wisdom also guides us in consuming information mindfully. Imagine a sensational headline about a political event. Instead of immediately reacting, a Stoic approach involves questioning the source’s credibility and seeking additional perspectives. By cultivating media literacy, we navigate the complexities of a 24/7 news cycle, filtering out sensationalism to uncover a more nuanced truth.

For instance, when confronted with conflicting reports on a current event, a Stoic mindset would encourage us to dig deeper. Are there primary sources? What context might be missing? By applying Stoic discernment, we become active participants in shaping our understanding of the world, resisting the urge to be swayed by the loudest voices or the most sensational headlines.

Empathy in Online Discourse 

Online interactions often lack the nuance of face-to-face communication. When confronted with a strongly worded opinion, Stoic empathy becomes our bridge to understanding. Imagine a heated comment section discussing a controversial topic. A Stoic mindset invites us to consider the experiences and motivations behind diverse perspectives. This practice of empathy fosters connection in digital spaces, creating an environment conducive to meaningful exchanges.

For example, think of a discussion about a social issue where opinions vary widely. Instead of immediately dismissing opposing views, a Stoic approach prompts us to ask questions. What life experiences might have shaped these perspectives? How can we find common ground without compromising our principles and convictions? This Stoic empathy transforms online discourse from a battlefield of opinions into a forum for genuine communication.

Corporate Culture Challenges

In the corporate realm as well, where opinions on strategy and leadership abound, Stoic principles offer a compass. When faced with conflicting viewpoints during a team meeting, the Stoic leader refrains from immediate judgment. Instead, they practice humility, seeking to understand the perspectives of team members. By fostering an environment where diverse opinions are valued, they embody Stoic equanimity in leadership, guiding their team through challenges with resilience.

Consider a scenario where a team is discussing a major shift in business strategy. Instead of imposing their own viewpoint, a Stoic leader actively listens to the opinions of team members. They encourage open dialogue, recognizing that the collective wisdom of the team often surpasses individual insights. This Stoic approach to leadership not only promotes a healthier workplace culture but also enhances problem-solving by considering a spectrum of perspectives.

Influencer Culture

The rise of influencers brings another layer to Aurelius’ teachings. Consider an influencer endorsing a product. The Stoic lens prompts us to question the perspective presented. Is the endorsement based on genuine belief, or is it a product of financial incentives? By practicing Stoic discernment, we navigate the world of influencers with a critical eye, separating authentic voices from those influenced solely by external factors.

Imagine encountering an Instagram post where an influencer passionately endorses a diet and exercise product. Before being swayed by the glamorous presentation, a Stoic perspective encourages us to delve deeper. What is the influencer’s relationship with the brand? Are they genuinely enthusiastic about the product, or is this merely a promotional endeavor? By applying Stoic discernment, we guard against being influenced by content that might prioritize commercial interests over authentic experiences.

Applying Stoic Wisdom in Our Digital Odyssey

As we navigate the complexities of the digital age, Marcus Aurelius’ wisdom becomes a practical guide, offering insights into cultivating a Stoic mindset. In a landscape saturated with opinions and perspectives, the Stoic approach involves digital humility, equanimity in the face of online drama, discernment in information consumption, empathy in online discourse, and thoughtful reflection in the workplace and influencer culture.

Through these practical examples, we can weave Stoic principles into the weave and weft of our digital lives, navigating subjectivity with resilience and wisdom. Digital humility enables us to approach information with a discerning eye, recognizing that behind every post, tweet, or article lies a subjective perspective. Stoic equanimity allows us to engage in online discussions without succumbing to emotional turmoil, fostering constructive dialogue. Discernment in information consumption transforms us into active participants in shaping our understanding of the world, resisting the allure of sensationalism.

In practicing empathy in online discourse, we bridge the gap between diverse perspectives, turning digital spaces into arenas of genuine communication seeking understanding. Likwise, in the workplace, Stoic wisdom guides leaders to foster environments where diverse opinions are not only heard but valued, enriching decision-making processes. And in the realm of influencers, a Stoic lens prompts us to question motivations and seek authenticity in an era dominated by curated content.

So we we embark on our digital odyssey, we would do well to allow Marcus Aurelius’ wisdom to serve as a compass, steering us through the noise and tumult of subjectivity. Also, by embracing Stoic principles in our online interactions, we not only become architects of our digital experience but also contribute to a more thoughtful and interconnected digital society. In the constant ebb and flow of information, Stoicism becomes a guiding philosophy, enabling us to navigate the currents with resilience, wisdom, and a steadfast commitment to truth.


*The views and opinions expressed on this website are solely those of the original authors and contributors. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of Spotter Up Magazine, the administrative staff, and/or any/all contributors to this site.

By Donovan Riley

Donavon Riley is a Lutheran pastor, conference speaker, author, and contributing writer for 1517. He is also a co-host of Banned Books and Warrior Priest podcasts. He is the author of the book, "Crucifying Religion” and “The Withertongue Emails.” He is also a contributing author to "The Sinner/Saint Devotional: 60 Days in the Psalms" and "Theology of the Cross".

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.